Table of Contents
According to etymology, the word immune derives from the Latin immunis, which means exempt from public service, untaxed; unburdened. By extension, the term immunity means exempt from a particular infectious disease, but the term is now in danger of being equated with exemption from employment because of vaccine mandates that have been implemented or proposed in some countries. In the UK, unvaccinated health-care workers in England faced the prospect of imminent dismissal for representing a perceived danger to both themselves and to vulnerable patients, although the UK government is now consulting on whether the mandate should be scrapped. Many vaccine mandates include those who are naturally immune—which constitutes a large proportion of health-care workers in view of SARS-CoV-2 exposure in the workplace. However, there are compelling arguments against such unilateral mandates that bear repeating from the standpoint of accumulated knowledge around viral respiratory tract infections and immunity.
The same has been shown for SARS-CoV-2; in one study, individuals exposed to natural infection were ten-times less likely to be reinfected compared with vaccinated individuals without natural infection (adjusted hazard ratio 0·02, 95% CI 0·01–0·04 for previous infection vs 0·26, 0·24–0·28 for vaccination). Individuals exposed to natural infection were also less likely to be admitted to hospital with COVID-19.
Therefore, individuals with immunity resulting from natural infection are probably less likely to transmit the infection to vulnerable patients (who should themselves be vaccinated) compared with those who are vaccinated but not naturally immune. Long-term immunity in the upper airway cannot be directly measured, and serum antibody levels are not a surrogate for mucosal immunity.
However, based on the history of viral pneumonia and natural immunity, the scientific basis of this time frame is unclear—arguably it should be indefinite.
There is an ongoing shortage of health-care workers in England, which a vaccine mandate would probably exacerbate; indeed, this seems to be the primary factor in the UK government’s reconsideration of the policy. A strong component of averting a further crisis in health-care personnel should include making politicians aware of the power of natural immunity in individuals who have recovered from COVID-19.
I declare grants from Pfizer and Janssen, outside the submitted work.
References
- 1.
The human antibody response to influenza A virus infection and vaccination.
Nat Rev Immunol. 2019; 19: 383-397
- 2.
Necessity of COVID-19 vaccination in previously infected individuals.
Clin Inf Dis. 2022; ()
- 3.
Mumps outbreaks in vaccinated populations—is it time to re-assess the clinical efficacy of vaccines?.
Front Immunol. 2020; 112089
- 4.
Hybrid Immunity.
Science. 2021; 372: 1392-1393
- 5.
Fachliche Vorgaben des RKI für COVID-19-Genesenennachweise.
Article Info
Publication History
Published: February 07, 2022
Identification
Copyright
© 2022 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.